A few months ago, The Financial Diet published a post titled, Why You Need to Clean Out Your Junk Financial Beliefs (& How to Start), which really got the wheels churning in my head. TFD is a hit-or-miss publication for me because I find that a lot of the writers are immensely privileged and it’s hard to relate to a lot of their articles. But this one… this one really hit home for me and had me combing through my own belief systems, the way I was raised, and how it all affects the way I view my finances today.
As many of you know, I grew up poor and this was mostly due to the fact that my dad had a rather significant gambling problem. Without it, we could have lived a fairly comfortable middle-class existence, but as it was, we struggled to make ends meet on my mom’s preschool teacher salary. My dad’s paycheck (and sometimes, some of my mom’s…) was used to fund his gambling addiction. So, I grew up on free school lunches, eviction notices, and that survivor mindset. In my family, wealth was not something to strive for. Making it to the next paycheck without the lights getting turned off was. Things like 401ks, savings, and investments were not in the conversation. The biggest vacation we took as a family was when we went to Ohio. My dad drove the 1,200 miles from Clearwater to Toledo, and we stayed with relatives.
So all this to say… I have a lot of junk financial beliefs. I have had to work through a lot of shit, and I’m still working through it because it’s only been in recent years that I’ve been able to feel like I’m finally getting a good handle on my money. But I still fall prey to my junk financial beliefs, so let’s talk about them, shall we?
Deep breaths. I’m about to get real personal about these.
Junk Financial Belief #1: Working a second job is beneath me.
I’m not talking about having a side hustle, like freelance writing. I’m talking about getting a second job, usually in the retail space. Whether that’s working at the local Starbucks or the mall, I cannot bring myself to “lower myself” to get a second job, even though I know I could pay down my student loans so much faster if I did that, not to mention I could have a bit of breathing room in my budget. But there’s something about doing that that feels like defeat. I’m a college graduate! I have a full-time job! I shouldn’t have to also work a second job. (Yeah, I have a bit of that millennial entitlement going for me, I guess.)
If I did get a second job, it would solely be to pay off my student loans faster and build up my savings. Which means I would only have to work said job for a handful of years. It wouldn’t be forever, but I just can’t bring myself to do it. It would significantly eliminate my free time, and I’m not willing to give that up. I also think it would affect my mental health because part of my self-care routine involves lots of sleep and alone time. That’s partially why I haven’t tried harder to find more freelancing opportunities; it takes a lot of my mental energy – mental energy that’s already at a more limited capacity than most people.
Junk Financial Belief #2: I will always struggle with money.
I have a scarcity mindset when it comes to my finances. I never feel like I’ll ever have enough money, even though I actually do. I’m able to pay my bills, put food on the table, go on vacation. But I don’t save as much as I would like, I have credit card debt, and I always feel as if I’m working at a deficit when it comes to my budget. And it all feels very natural to me to have this unhealthy relationship with my finances. That’s the way I was raised, always fearing that one bill that could turn our world upside down, and that’s the way I live today, even though I don’t need to. In order to rise above this, perhaps this is where blogs like Kiana Danial review can be of aid.
This belief about struggling with money has deep roots in my past, but also my present because most of my family also struggles with money to this day. And there’s this part of me that feels selfish when I think about not struggling – do I really deserve that feeling of peace and fulfillment when it comes to money? Have I earned it?
It’s a lot to think about. I know I deserve that peace. I know my family members also deserve that peace. And I know it ultimately comes down to getting honest about my budget, eliminating the things that are holding me back from ultimate financial freedom, and allowing myself to claim a sense of ownership over my own money situation.
Junk Financial Belief #3: Extra money is supposed to be spent, not saved.
Growing up, having extra money was like finding a unicorn on the side of the road. As in, we almost never had it. I still don’t know how my parents afforded Christmas gifts, but I suspect it was a very stressful time for my mom. Savings wasn’t part of my lexicon growing up, and it’s only been in recent years that I’ve realized that having a well-funded savings account is something I need. It’s not something that would be nice-to-have, but it’s something that would allow me to stop depending on my credit card when emergencies arise (like, say, if my tire blows out one morning on the highway).
I’m getting better at this, but I can’t lie. Sometimes when I log on to my banking account and see that I have more money sitting in my checking account than I thought… it’s hard not to immediately place an order on Thriftbooks or start perusing the Old Navy website. It’s a mindset shift, but I know that the pleasure of seeing four figures in my savings account will far outweigh the pleasure of getting that shipment notification in my email inbox.
Junk Financial Belief #4: It’s normal to use credit cards to buy the things you want.
Oy vey. This has been a belief that I’ve been working on dismantling for years now. It’s the whole “buy now, pay later” mindset, and it’s a very popular one. I know I’m not the only one who has fallen into this trap. It started when I was given my first credit card at the tender age of 18. It had a $500 limit and I used it responsibly. I paid it off every month, using it to buy new items for my dorm room. Then, during my sophomore year of college, I stood in front of an Old Navy store, thinking about how I just really wanted some new clothes for summer, but I didn’t have the money to do so. I was talked into applying for an Old Navy credit card, and my jaw about hit the floor when I was approved and told my limit was $2,500. Within a year, that card was maxed out and I had no way to pay even the minimum payment. Eventually, I worked out a payment plan and paid off that card. But I never lost the shame attached to maxing out a credit card during the first year of my twenties, effectively ruining my credit. I had always told myself I was going to be better about my finances than my parents were, and here I was, my first time out as an adult, and I fucked it up royally.
That card is when I got into this mindset of buying now, paying later. And while I have worked hard to dispel myself of this… I have to constantly fight against myself. For example, just a few weeks ago, I spent an entire evening on ThredUp, throwing shirt after shirt into my cart and telling myself I “needed” these shirts because the dress code at work had recently changed. I didn’t have the money in my checking account, so I told myself I would put it on my credit card and “next paycheck, I’ll really get serious about my budget.” (<— anyone else do this? Sigh.) Thankfully, I came to my senses before I spent any money. I had to remind myself that if I don’t have money in my checking out, I don’t have money. It’s a mantra I have to constantly repeat to myself because it’s so easy to get caught up in buying things and putting it on credit. Part of it has to do with growing up poor and spending the first half of my twenties poor. I couldn’t buy things, ever, so now that I have the ability to, it’s so much harder to resist my impulses. But I’m trying and it starts by dispelling this financial belief that I can buy whatever I want using my credit card. To reinforce your commitment to financial discipline and gain practical strategies, consider enrolling in courses at therlworld.com.
Honestly, I could probably write another 1,500 words on other junk financial beliefs I have, but I think this post has gotten too long already (maybe I’ll write a Part II in the future). These are some of my bigger ones, and it’s not easy to come clean about all of this. But it’s important. It’s important to talk about money and open up about the way our past has defined our present. It doesn’t mean I still abide by these beliefs or that I’ve thrown in the towel. No – I am actively working on dismantling them so that I can have that elusive financial freedom sometime in the future. That’s all I can ask of myself.
Your turn! Tell me one junk financial belief of your own.
Suzanne
This is such a great post, and I would DEFINITELY read a Part II. It is so fascinating to me how differently people think about money. I was really fortunate that my mom did the work that you are doing now, to change her own financial mindset after growing up poor. Add that to the fact that my father had good financial role models, and I really lucked out. But that doesn’t mean that I don’t have Junk Financial Beliefs, too. (I have spent several minutes trying to describe my biggest one, but I am failing. So I will just leave it there.) They are super hard to overcome! I applaud you for taking such a close look at your own beliefs — it is inspiring me to do a deeper analysis of my own thinking about money.
Stephany
Yeah, I think we all have our own junk financial beliefs, even if we come from a family that taught us good financial behaviors. It was interesting to me to really dig into mine and figure out exactly where they came from and how to change my mindset. Thanks for leaving such a supportive comment – means the world to me!
StephTheBookworm
I love this post and I think SO many people can relate to this. It seems like a huge majority of people live on credit cards. I like to think I’m pretty decent about credit cards, but I have bad phases where I buy everything up and run up the bill and I hate that. That’s why we have such a large personal loan out right now – we used it to pay off high interest, high balance cards. I seriously fantasize about being debt free. Saving money is hard, and spending “extra” money on debt instead of something fun is hard. Some weeks I can do it with ease, and some weeks I struggle. All we can do is keep chugging along and do the best that we can as individuals!
Stephany
I think about all the “extra” money I could have in my bank account if I didn’t have to worry about paying off my school loans and credit card debt. It would be SO nice! And I’ll get there – just have to prioritize paying those off right now, so I can live a more debt-free existence in the future. We’ll make it happen!
San
Great, honest post, Stephany. I appreciate how open you have been about finances lately.
We definitely all have junk beliefs and it’s important to talk about them.
Luckily, the whole credit card concept doesn’t exist in Germany, so I never thought of credit cards as a means to finance something I couldn’t otherwise afford.
Stephany
Oh, that’s so interesting that Germany doesn’t have the same concept towards credit cards that we do in the United States. That would have definitely saved me some financial woes if I had grown up with the same belief, ah!
Rachel M
A few thoughts to share: 1- don’t be so hard on yourself, the first step is admitting you have a problem. With credit card companies (& Old Navy) throwing themselves at prospective clients, I’m amazed anyone can refuse 2- recognizing your triggers is a huge step in changing your future behavior. Be proud that you have such great self awareness. 3- I also came from a challenging childhood. My father drank (rather than gambled) the rent away. On the plus side, it teaches you how NOT to be an adult. All of that said, my biggest recommendation for you is to shift how you think about saving. Rather than viewing it as spend now (yippee), think about saving as spending later – but with the benefit of bonus gifts such as compound interest, knowing what you really want, and joy of additional financial security. It’s not an easy road but it is one well worth traveling. PS – instead of thinking of a second job as a failure, consider thinking of it as a way to gain additional skills or push your boundaries. Just a thought
Stephany
I really didn’t think I was being hard on myself with this post – it was more of an exercise in digging into my past and figuring out where some of my beliefs come from when it relates to money. I think I’m doing a great job with my finances, considering where I came from, and I’m proud of the steps I have taken. Could I be doing better? You bet. But harping on that doesn’t get me any closer to my goals.
I definitely see the value in a second job and I wish it was something I could do since it would really make my finances more stable, but I think it was significantly affect my mental health and I have to protect this area of my life. I need lots of downtime to keep my anxiety and depression at bay, and a busy job interacting with people all weekend could be harmful for that goal. But I definitely understand your point there!
Lisa of Lisa’s Yarns
I am loving your finance posts. You are so brave to put yourself out there. But we need to be more open about finances because then maybe there would be better education and less shame around money.
I was very very lucky to be raised in a middle class household with parents who were extremely good with money. They often tell the story about how they went out for their five year anniversary and only had $10 to spend. They thought it would be plenty to buy a nice meal (this was back in 1979). The restaurant was more expensive than they thought and they could only afford to each get a bowl of soup. I guess my dad got really frustrated and it almost ruined their celebration. But they tell this story to us to remind us that they had to be really frugal in the early years of their marriage. Now they live very comfortably but it wasn’t always that way.
That said, I was not always as good with money as I am now. I took out way too many loans for grad school and had a lot of shame about them. Then I met Phil and was inspired by the fact that he had no debt so I worked my butt off to pay them off. I was also lucky to work with a guy who has become my mentor and he told me to put every bonus towards my student loan debt. He also told me to remember we are well-compensated because of the volitility of the financial services industry. Lots of people in my industry fall into the trap of spending what they make and then they lose their job and have nothing saved. So I vowed not to do that!
Stephany
You are truly inspiring with the way you tackle personal finance. I know you work in a well-compensated industry, but like you said, you still have to be careful about not living above your means and spending everything you make! You still live frugally and budget accordingly. And the way you paid off your grad school loans is nothing short of impressive!
Brian
Had to give drop thriftbooks like a bad habit. Buy books at thrift stores for 50 cents or $1 now. Deleted every book from my wishlist. Read the books you have and can cheaply get your hands on. The other books will still exist to be read another day.