What I’m Reading (4.24.23)

To Sir, with Love by Lauren Layne (★★☆☆☆)

E-Book • Libby • Contemporary Romance • 2021

Short synopsis: When Gracie’s father passed away, she put away her dreams of becoming an artist to run his champagne shop. But the shop is failing and when a wealthy buyer offers to take over her store, she’s unsure what to do. So she takes solace in Sir, the nameless, faceless man she met on a dating app whom she’s been conversating with for months.

Lauren Layne has been a consistently good romance author for me, but this book was not it. Her character development and plots usually feel fresh and fun, but this one felt stale and overdone. It’s a reimagining of You’ve Got Mail, and this is a plot that has been done so many times and she didn’t really bring anything original to the plot. There was no heart to this novel and there was nothing more going on than the central romance. I just wanted more. What did I like about this novel? I enjoyed the relationships: between Gracie and her siblings, Gracie and her stepmom, Gracie and her friends. I enjoyed the slow build of the relationship. But the rest of it? MEH. And I just could not stop being squicked out by Gracie calling this faceless person on a dating app “Sir.” (He called her “Lady.” All of the eye rolls.)

The Golden Couple by Greer Hendricks and Sarah Pekkanen (★★★★☆)

Print • Owned (Book of the Month) • Thriller • 2022

Short synopsis: Marissa and Matthew seem to be the couple that has it all: a beautiful home, high-powered careers, and a wonderful little boy. But when Marissa confesses to an affair and they start couples therapy with the unconventional counselor, Avery, their life—and Avery’s—becomes even more complicated and dangerous.

This was an excellent thriller! I really did not know what I expected from the ending, but I was truly surprised by it. I loved the twists and turns of this thriller. Every time I thought I was putting everything together in my head, the authors would throw in some new unexpected twist. It was such a smart, well-written thriller. Of course, Avery as a therapist is not following any of the ethical protocols and you just have to suspend your belief in that aspect of the book. (And there are some reasons I won’t get into that make it a bit easier to suspend that belief.) All in all, a satisfying thriller that was fun to read.

In a New York Minute by Kate Spencer (★★★★☆)

E-Book • Libby • Contemporary Romance • 2022

Short synopsis: On the worst day of Franny’s life, she becomes a viral meme after a man on the subway gives her his jacket when she has a really embarrassing wardrobe malfunction. The whole world, it seems, wants to push the two of them together, though they couldn’t be more badly matched. When fate continually seems to push them together, will they start to realize that opposites do attract?

This story was so sweet! I loved the meet-cute on the subway, and I was curious about how the author would continue to get these characters back together throughout the novel. And the way she pushed these characters together felt very natural! I also really enjoyed how Franny and Hayes’ relationship developed beyond that original meet-cute. There was a lot of “will they/won’t they” tension that didn’t get too over the top. There was just enough tension that their eventual “will they” felt so satisfying. At the beginning of the book, it felt as if Hayes was written to be on the spectrum based on some character details, but those details sort of fell away the deeper I got into the book. I don’t know if this is a flaw on the author’s part, but it was something I noticed. And while I truly hated the ending (I won’t give it away, but it’s a romance novel trope that really bugs me and I never think it’s necessary), it wasn’t enough to make me hate the novel. It’s a romance I can safely recommend to most people!

What are you reading?