The question I was asked the most growing up was, “Why are you so quiet?”
It’s such a bad question because how is someone supposed to respond to that? I just… am? That’s the way my personality works?
One time, way back in 2016, I went to this event with two friends I knew and a bunch of people I didn’t know. It was right after Trump was elected, and we were brainstorming ways we could effect change. I felt good at that event, like I had contributed a fair amount within the group. I didn’t contribute as much as other people, but I felt like I had stepped outside my comfort zone more than I usually do.
The next day, a friend said to me, “You were so quiet last night!”
Ughhhhh. Even when a quiet person tries, an extrovert doesn’t see the effort. (Not all the time, but sometimes.)
I’m quiet because this is just who I am. I do not want to monopolize the conversation, and I don’t need to tell everyone every thought that’s zipping through my brain. Because, believe me, just because I’m sitting and listening doesn’t mean my mind isn’t whirring 100 miles a minute. My brain is never silent; it’s actually pretty exhausting to be inside my head, and I wish it could be silent sometimes.
The other reason I’m quiet is that I have social anxiety. I get very nervous when I have to be in a public place with tons of different people (for almost any social event, even if it’s with people I know well, I will spend the weeks leading up to it overanalyzing every little logistical detail and everything that could go wrong). I don’t want to monopolize the conversation because I struggle with word retrieval when all the attention is on me. I get embarrassed when people are looking at me and stressed that the point I’m trying to make won’t come across the way it sounds in my head. Sometimes, it’s just easier to be quiet. To let the conversation flow around me and interject an opinion or a funny quip here and there.
I get extremely nervous when I meet up with a blog friend for the first time. Everyone always talks about how easily the conversation flows when you’re together because you already know each other through your blogs. But I’m always stressed that I’m going to be the one blog friend they can’t make easy conversation with because I’m quiet and shy and take time to warm up to people, even people I know through blogging. For the most part, this hasn’t happened, but I also can’t pretend that conversation always comes naturally. And that’s just because it’s not easy for me to make conversation with anyone, whether I’ve read their blog for years or not!
I’ve come to accept my quietness, although it’s not exactly something I love about myself. I wish I were a sparkling conversationalist (I even read the book Supercommunicators to see if I could learn), but it’s just not who I am.

Oh Stephany! I feel all of this SO intensely. This is exactly me. (My in laws have known me for 25 years now and they still ask me why I am so quiet! Argh!) I think you and I would get along fabulously and we could sit in calm and quiet and read and pet cats. Except, lol, I think we would both be super tense for the first [interminable time period] while we built up the comfort required to feel okay being silent.
Same. Same same same! Life is so hard for shy introverts, and it makes it so much worse when someone mentions how quiet you are. I’ve outgrown it a bit. Like I’m more comfortable speaking out in a group- but if it’s a larger group and I’m saying something, I’m also aware that I’m speaking while I’m doing it, if that makes sense. Like I’ll be making my point while simultaneously being aware that I’m speaking in front of a group, and that it feels kind of weird and scary but somehow I’m still doing it… I’m sure whatever I’m saying suffers from all this distraction!
I also get nervous about meeting people one on one (ha, this is funny because you and I have met SEVERAL times). I like a slightly larger get together- like three or four people. I guess that’s because I don’t feel the pressure to carry the conversation. Sigh. Non-shy extroverts don’t know how easy they have it!
I totally get it. My in-laws are very extroverted, chatty people. I can absolutely hold my own in a conversation, but I’m not likely to butt in and start talking. Sometimes waiting for a natural break in the flow of conversation means that a topic will pass me by without having said anything, and I’m OK with that. If it’s really important I’ll jump in, but often it drifts over me. Sometimes my MIL will want to invite me into the conversation, but she does it by turning to me suddenly and saying ‘Julie is quiet’. It took me decades to realize that she was trying to make an opening in the conversation for me, but honestly it makes me feel criticized and my brain freezes up, so it’s counter productive. Now I’m thinking it will happen at Thanksgiving. Sigh.
I’m so grateful for the quiet people. If everyone were as loud as I am, the world would be a terrible place!!
I used to hate discussion-based classes in college because for the most part, by the time I thought through how I felt about the topic, the conversation had moved on. The world doesn’t really recognize that people process differently! Totally agree with J that “Sometimes waiting for a natural break in the flow of conversation means that a topic will pass me by without having said anything.”